Incomplete Thought: Cloud Capacity Clearinghouses & Marketplaces – A Security/Compliance/Privacy Minefield?
With my focus on cloud security, I’m always fascinated when derivative business models arise that take the issues associated with “mainstream” cloud adoption and really bring issues of security, compliance and privacy into even sharper focus.
To wit, Enomaly recently launched SpotCloud – a Cloud Capacity Clearinghouse & Marketplace in which cloud providers can sell idle compute capacity and consumers may purchase said capacity based upon “…location, cost and quality.”
Got a VM-based workload? Want to run it cheaply for a short period of time?
…Have any security/compliance/privacy requirements?
To me, “quality” means something different that simply availability…it means service levels, security, privacy, transparency and visibility.
Whilst one can select the geographic location where your VM will run, as part of offering an “opaque inventory,” the identity of the cloud provider is not disclosed. This begs the question of how the suppliers are vetted and assessed for security, compliance and privacy. According to the SpotCloud FAQ, the answer is only a vague “We fully vet all market participants.”
There are two very interesting question/answer pairings on the SpotCloud FAQ that relate to security and service availability:
How do I secure my SpotCloud VM?
User access to VM should be disabled for increased security. The VM package is typically configured to automatically boot, self configure itself and phone home without the need for direct OS access. VM examples available.
Are there any SLA’s, support or guarantees?
No, to keep the costs as low as possible the service is offered without any SLA, direct support or guarantees. We may offer support in the future. Although we do have a phone and are more than happy to talk to you…
:: shudder ::
For now, I would assume that this means that if your workloads are at all mission critical, sensitive, subject to compliance requirements or traffic in any sort of sensitive data, this sort of exchange option may not be for you. I don’t have data on the use cases for the workloads being run using SpotCloud, but perhaps we’ll see Enomaly make this information more available as time goes on.
I would further assume that the criteria for provider selection might be expanded to include certification, compliance and security capabilities — all the more reason for these providers to consider something like CloudAudit which would enable them to provide supporting materials related to their assertions. (*wink*)
To be clear, from a marketplace perspective, I think this is a really nifty idea — sort of the cloud-based SETI-for-cost version of the Mechanical Turk. It takes the notion of “utility” and really makes one think of the options. I remember thinking the same thing when Zimory launched their marketplace in 2009.
I think ultimately this further amplifies the message that we need to build survivable systems, write secure code and continue to place an emphasis on the security of information deployed using cloud services. Duh-ja vu.
This sort of use case also begs the interesting set of questions as to what these monolithic apps are intended to provide — surely they transit in some sort of information — information that comes from somewhere? The oft-touted massively scaleable compute “front-end” overlay of public cloud often times means that the scale-out architectures leveraged to deliver service connect back to something else…
You likely see where this is going…
At any rate, I think these marketplace offerings will, for the foreseeable future, serve a specific type of consumer trafficking in specific types of information/service — it’s yet another vertical service offering that cloud can satisfy.
What do you think?
- Spotcloud launches cloud computing clearinghouse (zdnet.com)
- Are There Tax Breaks in The Cloud? (datacenterknowledge.com)
- SpotCloud Launches Today: What Kind Of An Impact Will It Have? (cloudave.com)
- ComputeNext: Google For Compute Resources (cloudave.com)
- ScaleUp Enables A Federated Cloud Ecosystem (diversity.net.nz)
- Dark Clouds: Can you trust the Cloud? Panel on Feb 4th at Cloud Communications Summit in Miami (voipsa.org)