From the Concrete To The Hypervisor: Compliance and IaaS/PaaS Cloud – A Shared Responsibility
* Update: A few hours after writing this last night, AWS announced they had achieved Level 1 PCI DSS Compliance.* If you pay attention to how the announcement is worded, you’ll find a reasonable treatment of what PCI compliance means to an IaaS cloud provider – it’s actually the first time I’ve seen this honestly described:
Merchants and other service providers can now run their applications on AWS PCI-compliant technology infrastructure to store, process and transmit credit card information in the cloud. Customers can use AWS cloud infrastructure, which has been validated at the highest level (Level 1) of PCI compliance, to build their cardholder environment and achieve PCI certification for their applications.
Note how they phrased this, then read my original post below.
However, pay no attention to the fact that they chose to make this announcement on Pearl Harbor Day 😉
Here’s the thing…
A cloud provider can achieve compliance (such as PCI — yes v2.0 even) such that the in-scope elements of that provider which are audited and assessed can ultimately contribute to the compliance of a customer operating atop that environment. We’ve seen a number of providers assert compliance across many fronts, but they marketed their way into a yellow card by over-reaching…
It should be clear already, but for a service to be considered compliant, it clearly means that the customer’s in-scope elements running atop a cloud provider must also undergo and achieve compliance.
That means compliance is elementally additive the same way “security” is when someone else has direct operational control over elements in the stack you don’t.
In the case of an IaaS cloud provider who may achieve compliance from the “concrete to the hypervisor,” (let’s use PCI again,) the customer in turn must have the contents of the virtual machine (OS, Applications, operations, controls, etc.) independently assessed and meet PCI compliance in order that the entire stack of in-scope elements can be described as compliant.
Thus security — and more specifically compliance — in IaaS (and PaaS) is a shared responsibility.
I’ve spent many a blog battling marketing dragons from cloud providers that assert or imply that by only using said provider’s network which has undergone and passed one or more audits against a compliance framework, that any of its customers magically inherit certification by default. I trust this is recognized as completely false.
As compliance frameworks catch up to the unique use-cases that multi-tenancy and technologies such as virtualization bring, we’ll see more “compliant cloud” offerings spring up, easing customer pain related to the underlying moving parts. This is, for example, what FedRAMP is aiming to provide with “pre-approved” cloud offerings. We’ve got visibility and transparency issues to solve , as well as temporal issues such as the frequency and period of compliance audits, but there’s progress.
We’re going to see more and more of this as infrastructure- and platform-as-a-service vendors look to mutually accelerate compliance to achieve that which software-as-a-service can more organically deliver as a function of stack control.
* Note: It’s still a little unclear to me how some of the PCI requirements are met in an environment like an IaaS Cloud provider where “applications” that we typically think of that traffic in PCI in-scope data don’t exist (but the infrastructure does,) but I would assume that AWS leverages other certifications such as SAS and ISO as a cumulative to petition the QSA for consideration during certification. I’ll ask this question of AWS and see what I get back.
- Navigating PCI DSS (2.0) – Related to Virtualization/Cloud, May the Schwartz Be With You! (rationalsurvivability.com)
- Seeing Through The Clouds: Understanding the Options and Issues (thesecuritysamurai.com)
- I’ll Say It Again: Security Is NOT the Biggest Barrier To Cloud… (rationalsurvivability.com)
- PCI 2.0 Allows For Compliant Clouds, Make Sure Your Service Providers Are PCI Compliant (securecloudreview.com)
- What’s The Problem With Cloud Security? There’s Too Much Of It… (rationalsurvivability.com)
- FedRAMP. My First Impression? We’re Gonna Need A Bigger Boat… (rationalsurvivability.com)
- Mixed Mode and PCI DSS 2.0 (brandenwilliams.com)
- The Future Of Audit & Compliance Is…Facebook? (rationalsurvivability.com)
- Incomplete Thought: Compliance – The Autotune Of The Security Industry (rationalsurvivability.com)